When Your Best Leaders Feel Like Imposters
- Helen Sprague
- Mar 5
- 3 min read
Imposter syndrome doesn’t just live in early‑career clinicians. It quietly shapes how your supervisors, team leads, and program managers show up in the room — how they make decisions, how they speak up, and how they model leadership to their teams.
In many care organizations, your most conscientious people are the ones most likely to doubt themselves. They worry they’re not experienced enough, not polished enough, not “leaderly” enough. On paper, they’re exactly who you want in leadership. Internally, they’re convinced they’re faking it — and that fear leaks into every decision.
The Imposter’s Voice in Leadership
How Imposter Syndrome Drives Overthinking and Overworking
The “imposter” is the internal voice that insists a leader doesn’t truly belong in the role.
For leaders in helping professions, that voice can sound like:
“You don’t know enough to make this call.”
“That idea isn’t good enough yet — keep working on it.”
“Who are you to lead others who’ve been here longer?”
It’s part stern authority, part anxious novice. It pushes leaders to over‑prepare, over‑explain, or defer to others who “seem more confident.” On the surface, it can look like humility. Underneath, it’s driven by fear.
What It Looks Like on the Floor
The imposter doesn’t just live in someone’s thoughts; it shows up in how they lead.
In day‑to‑day operations, that can look like:
Delaying decisions to do “just a bit more research.”
Softening or avoiding necessary feedback.
Letting louder voices set direction, even when the leader sees problems.
Over‑functioning — taking on work that should belong to the team.
From the outside, these leaders often seem dedicated and conscientious. From the inside, they’re bracing for the moment someone “finds out” they’re not enough.
The Cost to Teams and Organizations
When leaders equate authority with certainty, the imposter pushes them into one of two extremes: silence or overcompensation.
Both come at a cost:
Teams get inconsistent direction and unclear priorities.
Issues surface late because leaders hesitate to name problems early.
Psychological safety erodes — people sense the leader’s anxiety and become more cautious themselves.
Your most ethical leaders burn out from over‑preparing, over‑functioning, and never feeling “enough.”
Over time, organizations can misread this as a performance issue or “not being cut out for leadership,” when the real issue is an unaddressed leadership identity problem.
A Different Model of Authority
Healthy leadership identity does not mean “I always know.” It sounds more like:
“It is my role to make a call with the best information we have right now.”
“It is my responsibility to tell the truth, even when it’s uncomfortable.”
“It is not my job to absorb everything. It is my job to set direction, hold boundaries, and support people as they face reality.”
Practically, that sounds like:
“I don’t know yet, but I’ll find out and come back to you with clarity.”
and
“This decision is mine to make. Here’s what I’m considering, and here’s where I’m landing.”
That stance doesn’t erase the imposter voice. It puts it in context. The leader can notice self‑doubt without letting it run the meeting.
What Organizations Can Do
If you lead a care organization, assume this: your most thoughtful, ethically‑driven leaders are exactly the ones most likely to feel like imposters.
Ignoring that doesn’t make it go away. It just drives it underground, where it shows up as:
Hesitation in critical moments.
Over‑accommodation and blurred boundaries.
Leaders who quietly burn out and step down, convinced they “weren’t really leaders.”
Instead of treating this as a private confidence problem, you can:
Name imposter dynamics explicitly in leadership development.
Tie them to role clarity, authority, and boundaries.
Give leaders concrete scripts and decision frameworks that support a stable leadership identity under pressure.
This is the work I do with clinical and frontline leaders: helping them build a clear leadership identity that can hold imposter feelings without letting them drive the bus. If you’re seeing these patterns in your supervisors and team leads, this is a signal your organization has a leadership identity gap — not a talent deficit.
Comments